eap Mailing List: RE: RE: draft-adrangi-eap-network-discovery-11.txt

[Glen Zorn (gwz) (gwz]

Adrangi, Farid <mailto:farid.adrangi [at] intel.com> supposedly
scribbled:

> "
> If the peer responds with an EAP-Response/Identity containing an
> unknown realm after the local AAA proxy/server sends an identity
> hint, then the local AAA proxy/server MUST respond with an EAP
> Failure packet.  The local AAA proxy/server MAY also send an
> EAP-Notification message providing the reason for the failure."

> 
> Will this work for you?

I'm pretty sure that the EAP-{Request, Response}/Notification
exchange has to come before EAP Failure; if you could make that
sequential character clear (which I attempted to do, but apparently
failed), it would be great.

> 
> 
>> 3.  The message flows in the Appendix only shoe the success cases
--
>> it would be nice if at least one failure case was illustrated.
> 
> [FA] Ok.  I will a failure case to one of the delivery options.
> 
>>> 
>>>> 
>>>> ---------- Forwarded message ----------
>>>> Date: Sun, 3 Apr 2005 21:29:40 -0700
>>>> From: "Adrangi, Farid" <farid.adrangi [at] intel.com>
>>>> To: Bernard Aboba <aboba [at] internaut.com>
>>>> Cc: eap [at] frascone.com, iesg [at] ietf.org, Jari Arkko
>>>>      <jari.arkko [at] piuha.net>, gwz [at] cisco.com, jsalowey [at] 
>>>> cisco.com,
>>>>      Pasi.Eronen [at] nokia.com, Eugene Chang
<eugene.chang [at] funk.com>
>>>> Subject: RE: [eap] RE: FW: I-D
>>>>     ACTION:draft-adrangi-eap-network-discovery-11.txt
>>>> 
>>>> I don't recall talking about an IESG note on the mailing list!
>>>> Anyhow, as to your strawman IESG note, it should be noted that
the
>>>> draft was reviewed and accepted by IEEE 802.11 (WIEN? - the WG
has
>>>> sent an official review report to IETF.  And also, I would
remove
>>>> the last part of the note: "and it is not recommended for
>>>> implementation outside of 3GPP."  I think we should state the
>>>> facts about the solution and let the implementer decided
whether
>>>> or not the solution is suitable for their deployments outside
>>>> 3GPP. BR, Farid 
>>>> 
>>>>> -----Original Message-----
>>>>> From: Bernard Aboba [mailto:aboba [at] internaut.com]
>>>>> Sent: Saturday, April 02, 2005 5:08 PM
>>>>> To: Adrangi, Farid
>>>>> Cc: eap [at] frascone.com; iesg [at] ietf.org; Jari Arkko;
gwz [at] cisco.com;
>>>>> jsalowey [at] cisco.com; Pasi.Eronen [at] nokia.com; Eugene Chang
>>>>> Subject: RE: [eap] RE: FW: I-D
>>>>> ACTION:draft-adrangi-eap-network-discovery-11.txt
>>>>> 
>>>>> 
>>>>> I think we were talking about an IESG note in addition to
material
>>>>> in the applicability statement, no?
>>>>> 
>>>>> For example, EAP SIM contains the following note:
>>>>> 
>>>>> IESG Note
>>>>> 
>>>>> The EAP-SIM protocol was developed by 3GPP.  The documentation
of
>>>>> EAP-SIM is provided as information to the Internet community.
>>>>> While the EAP WG has verified that EAP-SIM is compatible with
EAP
>>>>> as defined in RFC 3748, no other review has been done,
including
>>>>> validation of the security claims.
>>>>> 
>>>>> Here is a potential strawman note for the EAP Network
Discovery
>>>>> document: 
>>>>> 
>>>>>  EAP Network Discovery was developed by 3GPP.  Documentation
is
>>>>> provided as information to the Internet community.  While the
EAP
>>>>> WG has verified that EAP Network Discovery is compatible with 
>>>>> EAP as defined in RFC 3748, no other review has been done,
>>>>> including investigation of potential security issues.  There
is
>>>>> work underway in IEEE 802.11 which may provide similar
>>>>> functionality, enabling an EAP peer to determine network
>>>>> availability prior to  handoff. As a result, the approach
>>>>> described in this document may  be superceded by future
>>>>> standards, and it is not recommended for implementation
outside
>>>>> of 3GPP. 
>>> 
>>> Hope this helps,
>>> 
>>> ~gwz
>>> 
>>> Why is it that most of the world's problems can't be solved by
>>>   simply listening to John Coltrane? -- Henry Gabriel
>>> _______________________________________________ eap mailing list
>>> eap [at] frascone.com http://mail.frascone.com/mailman/listinfo/eap
>> 
>> Hope this helps,
>> 
>> ~gwz
>> 
>> Why is it that most of the world's problems can't be solved by
simply
>>   listening to John Coltrane? -- Henry Gabriel
>> _______________________________________________
>> eap mailing list
>> eap [at] frascone.com
>> http://mail.frascone.com/mailman/listinfo/eap

Hope this helps,

~gwz

Why is it that most of the world's problems can't be solved by
simply
  listening to John Coltrane? -- Henry Gabriel