eap Mailing List: Re: Re: SHA-0 Broken

[Florent Bersani (florent.bersani]

Mohamad Badra wrote:

> I am not opposed to any protocol. Let me answer you by a question: why 
> I have to create 'new' one? Why I shall create a new protocol whereas 
> I already have the same services if I partially or if I simplify the 
> use of IKEv2 or TLS?
The IMHO interesting question I asked you and that you apparently 
avoided to answer technically was: "why was IKEv2 invented since we 
already had TLS"?

I do not have definitive answers as I am currently working on such 
topics but I believe that an open-minded reflexion with scientific 
arguments on this question may bring many insights.

Florent, who, before taking winners, like to understand why they have 
won ;-)